Heat Pump vs Solar Pool Heating

Extend the swimming season by investing in the best type of pool heater.

Pool owners are always looking for ways to keep their pool water warm. One of the most popular methods is installing a solar pool heating system. Solar pools systems use a series of panels that capture and store heat from the sun during the day, releasing it into your pool at night when you need it most. There are many different types of solar heating systems on the market today to suit everyone’s needs and budgets. Equally as popular: the pool heat pump, which uses electricity to capture heat and feed it into the pool.

But which is better? A heat pump or a solar pool heater?

In this article, we weigh up the pros and cons of pumps and solar heater devices for delivering year-round warm water in your pool.

Heat Pumps

How Effective Are they?

Heat pumps will effectively heat your pool water during both the summer and winter months, but they’re not as fast at doing it as solar heaters. In the cooler months they may work a little harder than they do in the summer as they will have to heat more water in the winter to keep the pool warm while the temperature drops

They also use a lot less energy than other methods of heating. Fortunately, heat pumps are very efficient because they work all day long to keep your pool warm. However, heat pumps are not as efficient as solar panels because they need to work harder when heating up water in an expansive tank. Solar panels store heat in a tank or tubes, which is easier to transfer the heat using liquid than air.

If you’re looking for a quick solution, it’s best to look into solar heating systems instead of using an electric pump that needs time before it can make the water comfortable enough for swimming.


Pool heat pumps shouldn’t require much maintenance. However, it’s essential to ensure the pump is working properly and not malfunctioning. When you need to get your failing heat pump system fixed, you may need to contact a professional who can diagnose the problem. It’s also worth investing it regular checkups for your heat pump pool heater to make sure its working its best.

How Environmentally-Friendly Are They?

We all want a clean carbon footprint. But just how eco-friendly are heat pumps?

Heat pumps are more environmentally-friendly than other pool heating methods, but they still release carbon dioxide into the atmosphere.

If you want to have a really eco-friendly system that doesn’t require any sort of fuel and won’t release greenhouse gases, then invest in solar pool heating instead. Solar heaters use the sun’s rays to heat the water without any effort at all!

Cost of Pool Heat Pumps

There are two types of pool heater: gas or electric. Gas is cheaper and easier to install–but it’s not as effective in colder climates. It also needs more maintenance (such as replacing anode rods). The other type is electric, which requires an electrical outlet nearby. It’s more expensive but lasts longer–plus it heats up the water faster and uses fewer chemicals.

The cost of pool heater pumps is pretty pricey. For the product and installation, costs range between $3,000 and $5,000. Some models are more expensive than others. When you’re considering all of the factors, heat pumps are more expensive than solar.

Pool Heater Pump Lifespan

How long with your pool heater pump last? It depends on the type of pool heater you have. For example, for a gas or oil-fired heater, it’ll last about 20 years. But if you’re using an electric one, your pump will need to be replaced every five to ten years – depending on its condition and how often you use it.

Advantages and Disadvantages of a Heat Pump

To sum up, we’ve concluded the goods and the bads of gas and electric heat pumps for your pool. Take a look below to find out whether it’s right for you or not.

Some advantages to using a pool heater pump include:

– Lower installation cost than other heating methods

– No fuel costs, which means no extra expenses come wintertime when gas and oil are expensive

– More environmentally friendly since they use electricity to heat the water

Some disadvantages of using a pool heater pump include:

– Higher upfront cost

– Pool pump motors have a tendency to wear down and need replacing

– Voltage fluctuations can cause the pool pump motor to overwork

– If they go out, it is not easy for someone who is unfamiliar with electricity or plumbing systems to get them back up and running

– Heat pump could be loud with high output. This might not bother you if you live alone, but it may disturb your neighbors

Solar Pool Heating

How Effective are They?

Are solar pool heaters quick to heat your pool water? Yes! They’re the most efficient type of pool heater – and the most popular type of pool heater in the Southern hemisphere.

Solar pool heaters work by using the sun’s energy to heat up your pool water trough solar collectors. This works because solar energy is absorbed by the water, which in turn heats up and is then circulated back into your pool.

Solar pool heaters are not as efficient in winter months because the panel is less exposed to sunlight, but they still save money on heating bills and reduce your carbon footprint. Solar panels can be terraced or mounted on a south facing roof for maximum exposure to sunlight. If you don’t have a south facing roof, solar panels can be mounted on the ground.

One of the main advantages is that they are weather-resistant, so it doesn’t matter if you live in a hot or cold climate. They also don’t need any electricity to operate and there’s no complicated wiring involved–they’re very easy to install!

Solar panels collect heat and transfer it to the tubes. The water in those tubes is then pumped through your pool heating system, which heats the water up and circulates back into the solar panels for a continual heat exchange process.


Solar heating systems require little maintenance after installation. The panels should be cleaned off of debris like leaves, twigs, and bird droppings about every six months. But all in all there is not a lot of maintenance required.

Plus, they are easy to install. The solar heating system can be installed on the roof, by a pool deck or will even work for those with shaded pools that need some help staying warm. The best place to install the solar heating system is to have it on a south facing roof. They are easy to mount and need no batteries or electric to run. Ask a professional if you’d prefer not to do it yourself.

How Environmentally-Friendly Are They?

Want a cozy warm pool without its environmental effects playing on your conscience? The short answer is that solar heating is completely eco-friendly. Unlike traditional pool heaters, solar pool heating systems do not require gas or electricity to operate. So they help you save money on energy costs and decrease your carbon footprint at the same time. They also have no side effects on air quality or noise pollution and don’t produce any emissions into the atmosphere.

Cost of Solar Pool Heaters

The cost of solar pool heaters is worth the investment in the long-term. The cost for solar pool heaters ranges from $500 – $1500, but this will save you money because the panels last for 20-25 years and don’t need to be replaced often. Some models can be installed in about one day. Heat pumps are more expensive than solar pool heating systems because it needs to be installed by professionals and comes with an expansive tank system that heats water while the sun warms it up.

Solar Pool Heater Lifespan

Wondering how long a solar pool heater lasts? Solar heaters have a lifespan of 25 years, but this depends on the usage. The more often you use it and hours each day it is run, the shorter its life expectancy will be.

Advantages and Disadvantages of Solar Pool Heaters

Here, we sum up the positives and the negatives of solar pool heaters. Take a look below to find out whether it’s the best choice for your pool.

Some advantages to using a pool solar collector include:

– They’re easy to install

– Solar panels can be placed on any surface without hassle

– There’s no need for an outside power source – No utility cost

– They don’t use electricity to operate

– Low maintenance with long lifespan

Some disadvantages to using a pool solar collector include:

– Solar panels are expensive and may not be feasible depending on the size of your pool

– They are not as effective during cloudy and rainy weather

-Solar pool heating is a safe and sustainable way to heat your swimming pool

While it may seem like an expensive investment, the low cost of solar power means that you can save money on utility bills every month. Solar panels absorb sunlight during the day and turn it into electricity at night, so they are most efficient when positioned near a sun-soaked area.

Pump vs Solar: Which One Wins?

A common question among homeowners is which type of pool heater is better: a pump or solar?

Heat pumps and solar pool heaters each come with their pros and cons, but if you’re looking for a long-term investment in your swimming experience then the decision is clear: invest in a solar pool heater to extend those sweltering summer days. If you want a pool to be at the perfect temperature all day, go with solar panels. Solar is more expensive than heat pumps but it will save on your heating bill in the long run because there’s no electricity needed!

Think of solar as free energy for warming up the waters in your pool. As long as the sun is out, you can boost the degrees in your pool to enjoy swimming all year round. With a pool heater solar, you can heat your pool even when the air is cool outside. It’s essentially free energy – something you just can’t get from an electric heat pump.

Even though electric heat pumps are effective in increasing the temperature of your swimming pool, they can be expensive, noisy, and less eco-friendly. With a heater solar pool, as long as you have sun, you have a warm and delightful pool.

So if you’re looking for the most efficient way to heat a pool, we recommend choosing solar heating systems. They’re efficient, eco-friendly, long-lasting, and very wallet-friendly!

You may also like...

Popular Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *